Home › content

Will Internet Radio Survive the Royalty Sting?

Authored by Scott Goldberg on March 8, 2007 - 9:04pm.
Radio Cartoon Things seem backward in Audio Entertainment (AE) World.  XM-Sirius (or Xirius, as Doc Searls called it in his blog) looks like it might fall apart because of…what?  FCC pride?  That’s one explanation.  They created a rule at satellite’s outset saying one entity couldn't own both licenses.  But the landscape has changed so much since then that it’s preposterous to believe a merged entity represents a real anti-competitive threat.  Now internet radio stations, per the infinite wisdom of the Copyright Royalty Board (CRB), will face a royalty fee per stream (yes, each stream), making business, as many of them know it, potentially impossible. 

My internet radio site of choice is KCRW.com.  On the air today they begged for listeners to begin subscribing, or face a world without KCRW’s unique programming.  And believe me, given the CRB’s decision, I’m thinking about it.  I love KCRW.  It’s my AE source of choice.  Good enough to pay for, in fact.  But if I do so, I can almost guarantee I won’t subscribe to Xirius in the near future, especially considering the $10/month fee to my Napster subscription.  Why? Because I can’t justify subscribing to 3 (three!) AE sources at this point.  So isn’t that enough to convince the FCC that Xirius is anything but a monopoly? 


A reader wrote last week that the comparison of internet radio to Xirius is irrelevant because satellite radio mostly occurs in cars.  I take exception to that.  At our DMW office we have Sirius.  And yes, satellite’s great, but I also listen to KCRW and Napster in equal amounts at work.


What happens when PCs built in to automobiles become more common?  Anyone who attended CES this year can attest it’s not far away.  In fact, many people, like Jay Leno, already have it.  KCRW.com and Napster will soon be at the tip of my fingers while I’m driving.  And that $10 Napster subscription?  How will satellite compete with that?  By giving me Howard Stern?  I’m a huge fan of the guy, but it’s not enticing enough for the extra bucks.


And what about internet connectivity on phones?  When I can get all the music I want on my mobile for a $10 subscription fee, will I ever buy a 99 cent song again?  What would be the point?


Anyhow… I’m sure I’ve missed plenty of important points here.  So I ask you, Reader, what’s your take on all of this?


Scott Goldberg


Related Links:
Take our poll...
Will Consumers Benefit From The Proposed Sirius and XM Merger?
tags: Internet | Law | Radio | Satellite Radio | Sirius | PC | Napster | XM | KCRW | Scott Goldberg | Steaming |



Comments

Music on mobiles

Submitted by anonymous (not verified) on March 9, 2007 - 7:37am.
It will definitely be interesting to see if the current downloading model survives when subscriptions can easily be reached anywhere. But what about on airplanes and places you can't get the internet? I have read, though, that soon enough you'll be able to get internet on planes as well. So the question is really how often you'll be without internet in 5 - 10 years. In 10 years will it seem ridiculous that we once lost connectivity in so many places? Maybe.

PCs in cars

Submitted by anonymous (not verified) on March 9, 2007 - 10:08am.
That will be quite a problem for satellite radio.

A Death Knell For Internet Radio, A Step Backward For Blues

Submitted by anonymous (not verified) on March 9, 2007 - 12:52pm.
This move would be a major setback for Blues/Jazz/Folk and other genres of music that are presently enjoying international airplay for the first time. While satellite offers an alternative to what we had experienced before satellite radio, Blues listeners only have one station on XM and Serious. This may not seem like a problem to those content to listen to mainstream music, but internet offers a diversity within these different genres. Support internet radio and keep alternative music alive. Your Friends at Cross Harp Chronicles/ Blues Harp House Party www.crossharpchronicles.com www.live365.com/stations/bluesharphousepart

Internet Radio Lives On!

Submitted by Ann Nightingale (not verified) on April 17, 2007 - 9:02pm.
While the royalties may cause some Internet radio stations to fold, the rumors of its death are greatly exaggerated. There are many Internet Radio stations that negotiate royalty licenses directly with independent artists, and they will not be affected by these changes.

I'd encourage Internet Radio listeners to seek out Indie stations such as SongPlanet Radio at www.SongPlanet.com. I am sure they'd be surprised at the amazing music being produced by artists who are not on the mainstream charts.

This could be a great reason to explore something different AND support independent artists at the same time.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.