Sorry CNET, The Championship Gaming Series is Old News

Authored by Scott Goldberg on June 13, 2007 - 10:36am.
Championship Gaming Series 2CNET’s Daniel Terdiman posted an article about the Championship Gaming Series today, and it wouldn’t have been such a big deal had Terdiman not called it the “New video-game league” in his title.  The league, after all, has been going on for quite a while now, but maybe they don’t want you to know that.  I wrote a review of the Los Angeles leg of the series last December, which you can find below.  Having seen it firsthand, it’s obvious Terdiman doesn’t know much about the league, aside from his coverage of the draft at the Playboy mansion.  The piece comes off, to one who knows, like a cheerleading PR release more than a news story.  The reason?  Read my article to find out.


It’s also interesting that Terdiman mentions player salaries, which are supposed to be impressive.  “CGS represents probably the first time that video game players will be paid regular salaries to do what they do,” he wrote.  “The starting salary for a CGS player will be $30,000. That figure plus bonuses could bring the top players as much as $100,000 or more per year in income.”


While those are certainly significant numbers, especially so when you consider they’ll be made by people playing video games, Terdiman is again inaccurate.  A standard for serious pay has already been set by another league, Major League Gaming, who has signed its top 12 players, according to CEO Mike Sepso in this interview, to $1 million contracts.



Anyhow, the point is that the professional video game business is still in its infancy, and there are many competitors trying to become “The” league of choice.  It’s hard to argue that player salaries will truly dictate the winner 3-5 years from now, and based on that alone, Major League Gaming seems to be ahead.  The tournaments themselves should also be interesting, shouldn’t they?  I found the Championship Gaming Series disappointing.  Read on for details…


The ‘Pros’ & Cons of the Championship Gaming Series

Skeptics of professional video gamers (or “cyberathletes,” as they are sometimes known) often ask the same two questions: 1) How difficult is it, really, to play a video game?; and 2) Who cares about professional video gaming anyway? You’ll find various answers supporting both sides of the argument, but the Championship Gaming Series is hoping to cash in on one of them, that being the existence of an obvious passion for tournament play.  

One leg of the series, the Championship Gaming Invitational, took place on December 16th in Los Angeles. With $80,000 up for grabs, it seems cyberathletes are increasingly capable of leading a self-supporting career competing in tournaments. It remains unresolved, however, whether or not there is a fan base. 

What you’ll see in February on DirecTV channel 101 will have you believe there is. Though filmed before a live audience, the invitational was not “live” in the traditional sense. The filming took place over six grueling hours and several hundred takes for what will amount to a one-hour special. Nearly three hours passed before a single game was played because take after take was required for the various hosts to get their lines right.  

The audience was well juiced courtesy of Mountain Dew while prodded by caffeine-induced hosts for thunderstick-toting teens to “cheer louder!” at every opportunity. By the time the tournament began, the audience had shrunk by a third, and the number of annoyed parents sitting in the stands equaled the number of squealing teenagers.  

A defining moment took place backstage in the VIP lounge where three adults watched the taping on a plasma screen - one of them being the mother of a contestant, while the other two looked like they just came for the free drinks. Project Gotham Racing on Xbox 360 was still in the preliminary rounds, and as the host interviewed the winner of round 2, the mother said to her new acquaintances, “They work really hard at this, you know.” The other two looked at each other, then at the mother, and they all fell into laughter at the same time. 


The thing about professional gaming that the Championship Gaming Series fails to convey is that the best cyberathletes, people like Johnathan “Fatal1ty” Wendel, have truly gifted talent. It’s a combination of intelligence and hand-eye coordination that the average person simply does not possess. But that talent is impossible to appreciate, even for regular video gamers. Regardless of the hours you’ve logged playing Project Gotham Racing, it’s impossible to look at the contestants, playing for $10,000, without thinking, “What’s the big deal?” You have to compete against them to get a real sense of how poorly you stack up. 

The pressure, therefore, falls on the game developers. If professional tournaments have a future, they will thrive solely on the ability of the games to demonstrate indisputable talent.  

Other Observations 

  • Boost Babes are nothing new to gaming, and the Invitational had its fair share. There was also a fair share of references to the fact that good gamers might, with a little hard work, even attract such beautiful women one day. Backstage in the competitors’ lounge, the separation between the Boost Babes and the cyberathletes looked like an eighth grade dance. Professional cyberathletes, it appears, don’t yet hold the same sex appeal to women as professional ‘physical’ athletes do.

  • There were a good number of female competitors in attendance, however. I wondered: do boost babes work against the industry by turning off young females to compete?

  • Overall the production was top notch, and the venue, Barker Hanger at the Santa Monica Airport, was perfect for the size of the audience. On television, the whole thing will look like it took place in a basketball arena, which isn’t far from the reality.

  • It was obvious – from the VIP lounges, to the stages, and the bevy of plasma and LCD screens – that a lot of money went into the event. Someone clearly believes there is a big future in video game tournaments.

  • I don’t know what the official size of the audience was, but I was amazed how many people were there at the beginning. I asked several of them why they came. The most common answer? To be on television. I’m still undecided whether or not that is good news for the tournament industry.

  • Maybe the coolest part of the event took place backstage in the competitors’ lounge. H2i demonstrated a hand-eye testing computer program that many of the players used to warm up their hands and brains. The program tested 10 or so aspects of hand-eye speed and provided a rank and score to see how you stacked up. An accuracy percentage was also offered. It was interesting to see the amount one could improve attempting the test several times. It’s also a great example of the talent some gamers have. I scored 47% accuracy on my best attempt. I’d say the average competitor was in the low-80s.



Comments

I don't think you have the

I don't think you have the right to call out another journalist about this because it seems that you have some research to do yourself.
Technically, the CGS hasn't began. They have had tournaments, but that is different from a league. This new league, which it is, will change a lot in the gaming community.
Also, you cite "cyberathletes" a lot but fail to mention the creator of that term. Yet, you like to mention MLG a lot. Well, other leagues that have a big fanbase include CPL, WSVG, WCG, and ESWC. In South Korea you will see massive, MASSIVE, leagues such as Starleague - where grand final matches will have up to 100,000 in attendance.
Yet, you still question whether people would watch video games. "What's the big deal?" This question drives me nuts, it's like watching the NFL and saying "Why the hell am I watching other people play the game when I can go out and play it myself!" Because, humans like to be entertained by the elite. Whether they are elite actors, singers, or athletes. Professional gamers are no different.

Correction

The prior events we called Championship Gaming Invitational. They were invitational matches set up in LA and SF. This is something totally different. Championship Gaming Series is a new pro gaming league starting this summer. Also, MLG contracted the top 12 players, while CGS is contracting 60 in the US alone, and paying salary. This does not even count the other 5 global regions that will have salaried players as well.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Add image
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd><br><p> <b> <i> <img> <hr>
  • Images can be added to this post.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.