Rupert Murdoch vs. Steve Jobs in DMW’s New Poll

Authored by dmw on August 13, 2007 - 11:25am.

After a tight first round last week in which Jeff Bezos, Steve Jobs, Satoru Iwata, Rupert Murdoch, and Google’s Sergey Brin & Larry Page went head to head for the title of “The Most Powerful Player Today in Media, Entertainment, & Technology,” the readers responded with resounding support for Murdoch and Jobs.  Advancing them to the final round, take our new poll and tell us what you think.  And if you think neither is worthy of the title, or if you have a strong opinion why you chose one over the other, leave a comment and let us know.  Steve Hawley had the comment of the week last week when he wrote:

“The forces that Murdoch channels are as black as the night, as black as crude oil, the personification of evil. They will continue to do no good in the world.

Disney begat Snow White but remember the old adage "the Mouse has fangs." But that's Eisner's Disney, not Jobs' Disney (as Disney's biggest stockholder). You don't hear much about Apple being evil. Just a closed society. I would be too, if I held some of the world's most coveted intellectual property. Apple has changed the music business by partnering with it. It changed the publishing business 20-plus years ago. It changed movie production. It owns the media player category. It is king of human factors engineering.

If Jobs is Luke, Murdoch is Darth Vader. They are equally powerful and maybe best seen as opposing forces of good and evil. As ambassadors, respectively, of creativity and destruction.

But in the end, I believe that humanity is basically good, which is why I chose Steve Jobs.”

Comments

Rupert Murdoch

If you're talking about the most powerful person in media, Murdoch wins hands down - it's not even close. It's not supposed to be a personality contest, but what is the reality. The reality is Murdoch is powerful now, and he's about to become more powerful, ah, if he lives that long. Another thing, for those that know the history of Jobs, many of his workers have called him a tyrant, although afterwards they do say they think in some ways he made them better. When you get into all of this in detail, there really aren't that many differences between those that have been successful in media and business. They just have different styles and ways of marketing themselves.

Writing...

The commenter above is right. I'm wondering if the writer even knows what they are talking about. Luke and Vader? What the? Murdoch is the most powerful man in media. Oprah is the most powerful woman. Steve Jobs doesn't even play a huge role in New Media. I have a feeling that context was left somewhere outside of this column.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.